
Over the years (!!!) I have documented the saga concerning my embarrassingly long wait for broadband. Well, the good news is that on Friday, 13th January 2006, a BT engineer arrived to do things (details below), and the less-brain-damaged of my two domestic lines is running at just over 1Mbps. This is the culmination of a wait of
- *over 2 years since broadband became ‘available’ in our area (September 2003)
- *over 8 years since I installed wireless 2Mbps broadband in the school around the corner
- *over 11 years since I first saw ADSL from BT research labs
Hey, I’m a patient guy (I have to be, right?), but as you might expect there is more here than meets the eye. In fact, I have been calm and accepting since meeting with the key protagonists some time ago: in several meetings involving the action group at BroadBand For Milton Keynes, BB4MK.org, and the key players at BT concerned with delivering broadband to Milton Keynes, I got to understand the BT perspective and the difficulties they faced. For example, I came to learn how Quality Of Service is taken seriously enough by BT that they did not want premature rollout of high bandwidth to leave a swathe of disappointed customers. This is entirely reasonable. Also, I came to learn how the history of growth in Milton Keynes led to numerous artifacts, with new houses in old villages served by old trunking and ancient copper that wound its way in seemingly random paths, at the whim of the early construction teams (meaning that although I could see the broadband-enabled exchange from my window, the line circled through many miles of old routes, creating an impossible situation). BT indeed finally (summer 2005) dug up and replaced some old trunking in order to improve the overall signal strength to a relative small group of customers, and we are genuinely grateful for this effort and expense.
[The sad saga of how Milton Keynes got locked into ancient cable infrastucture that neither BT nor NTL wanted to upgrade is documented elsewhere. And yes, we looked into dedicated private lines, satellite, wireless self-start community, you name it: not feasible.]
So what’s the problem? Well, in the negotiations with BT over the connectivity for our little backwater community, I maintained only one consistent position throughout, which can be summarised as follows: “Regardless of what speed we achieve now, the key thing is to be elevated from perpetual second-class citizenship, because it’s obvious to anyone that much higher speeds are on the way for the rest of the {world; country; region; town; village}.” BT understood the stance, but I’m convinced that the future prospects are just as grim, even given the fibre-to-the-home trials that are now underway in other parts of Milton Keynes. The next section explains why.
Too little, too late?
Now I read, in a New York Times article, (“Hey, Baby Bells: Information Still Wants to Be Free” by RANDALL STROSS, 15th January 2006) the following interesting commentary:
In California, Comcast cable broadband provides top download speeds of 6 megabits a second for a little more than $50 a month. That falls well short, however, of Verizon’s 15-megabit fiber-based service offered on the East Coast at about the same price. But what about the 100-megabit service in Japan for $25 month? And better, much better: Stockholm’s one-gigabit service – that is, 1,000 megabits, or more than 1,300 times faster than Verizon’s entry-level DSL servce – for less than 100 euros, or $120, a month.
Ha! Americans are grumbling about how the phone companies are holding back progress with mere 6Mbps and 15Mbps connections! Take another look at my graph… this is about as reliable a long-term experiment as you’ll ever see in this niche: 10 years = 10x speed, as the graph clearly shows. That means I can expect 10Mbps by 2014, 100Mbps by 2024, and 1Gbps by 2034 (remember Stockholm has it as of 2005). That’s appalling. Am I greedy? I don’t think so: history shows that the consumer appetite for memory and bandwidth is insatiable. Music yesterday, video today, HDTV/Hollywood full-screen 6.1 Dolby tomorrow (or yesterday if you live in the right place). So, BT, no self-congratulatory remarks, please: there is absolutely no room for complacency!! And yes, I am indeed grateful for the understanding, time, work, and expense that went into dealing with our little backwater: it is much appreciated – really!
Finally… as promised above:
Summary of my own saga, quoted from my earlier blog entries
[24 September, 2003: Broadband In Milton Keynes Saga, Diary Entry 1]
today the new longer-reaching broadband is meant to be available.
Step 1: find a sensible URL, so Google broadband BT, which gives me www.bt.com/broadband
Step 2: No obvious ‘news’ anywhere on the site about the 24th September ‘changes’
Step 3: Enter my number into the ‘Broadband Availability Checker’… it comes back with
“For Telephone Number 01908xxxxxxx on Exchange BRADWELL ABBEY
Your exchange has broadband ADSL. However, the length of the telephone line between you and the exchange is too long for broadband ADSL. Thank you for your interest.”
[19 April, 2004: ADSL at home at last?]
The image at the top of the current blog entry is a modified version of one I optimistically posted earlier, believing I would get 512Kbps in April 2004, so the line still fits].
The graph on the right shows the longest experiment I’ve ever run (by chance), having been a steady domestic online user since 1973/74.
[5 July, 2004: Miserable NDO/BT/ADSL MK Trial Customer]
[Yes, that’s me: but hey, having personally risked my neck climbing up a church tower and helping to install the first wireless broadband relay point for the Milton Keynes schools network many years ago, I figure I’m entitled to feel a little sore about now apparently being the LAST person in the entire UK to receive a broadband connection… read my open letter below].
[21 July, 2004: More ADSL MK Trial saga]
Question: Will this user-for-32-years-of-the-Internet-since-the-original-ARPAnet-days and early-settler-of-the-broadband-wireless-landscape really be the last person in the UK to get domestic broadband? Here’s a followup to the 12-step saga I began earlier. [SUMMARY: on-again-off-again-on-again ‘possible’, ‘maybe’, ‘absolutely no way’, ‘I completely give up’ and finally ‘wait a minute, I have an idea…’]
[13 January 2006: Installation, success!]: A BT engineer arrived, and downgraded my ISDN line, as required for ADSL (my normal domestic line is still ‘out of reach’ of the ADSL-enabled exchange, although the 2 lines are side by side in the house; ‘Business ISDN’ was all I could use over the past few years, which is a separate saga). My upgraded FreeServe/Wanadoo dialup account, after a minor side-saga with Wanadoo (they had not emailed me the new account name, which differs in a very subtle way from the old account name), is now live and kicking. Hooray! Thanks, all, especially Nick and co at BB4MK, and also Haley and co at BT, for bearing with me and all the others throughout.
Technorati Tags: adsl, broadband, milton.keynes, bt